Apple's inconsistent interface

Who's the undisputed king of the GUI? Apple, of course. Why? Ease of use. There are dozens of studies that show that Macs improve people's performance in everyday tasks. One of the main reasons for this ease of use is consistency: the same menu items and the same keyboard shortcuts perform the same actions in different applications. As a result, you don't spend hours learning that it's Apple S to save in Word, Apple Option S in Excel, Shift F3 in Quark and so on.

So quick question guys: how do you right-click on a Mac (assuming you haven't got a two-button mouse that is)? Long-time Mac users will instantly answer “Hold down the Control key then click”. Try it now, if you've never tried it before. See? A whole range of commands you never knew existed will suddenly appear.

Another question then: how do you right-click in Word? That's right. It's Control click. How do you right click in the Finder? That's right. It's Control click.

Last question: how do you right-click in Safari? If you answered, Control click, you'd be right. Kind of. Try it on this web page and you'll get your menus. Try it on a Java applet though. Doesn't work does it? Why? Because the correct combination for a right-click is Command click. That's right. Hold down the Apple key instead.

Daft, isn't it? Insane even. How long would you try looking for a contextual menu if you didn't know that? You wouldn't. You'd give up.

Now I've looked and looked for a technological or usability reason for this, but can't find one. Anyone know why this should be?

Technorati Tags: , ,

Leave a comment

Recent Entries

  • MT 4.1 now out

    Movable Type 4.1 is now available, I notice. I gave it a try today and while there are obvious improvements everywhere, there are a couple...

  • MT4: Finally made it

    Finally. I've done it. I've made the switch. With the slight exception of MT Blogroll, which I can do without for now (but which...

  • MT4: nearly there

    Tried again with my bi-weekly MT4 upgrade attempt. We're nearly there now, I reckon. Simply Threaded was giving me some problems and not showing...

  • MT-MyBlogLog

    I've been trying to 'Voxify' my media blog of late. That's included comment threading, relative dates, changes to stylesheets, etc. But the biggest change...

  • MT4: not yet

    The observant will have noticed that I've still not migrated my blogs over to MT4. I did have an abortive attempt at it last...

Close